Why Sindhi Hindus are repeating their mistakes ??

Veegas is an well known columnist writing for Frointer Post (in English) as well as Daily Ibarat (Sindhi). At a time when Sindh is trough massive upheavals which could be equated only to that of Partition and more important mass migration of Hindu Sindhis from Sindh.

Ever since the issues of abduction and Forced conversation issue came up, Veengus trough her writings have been raiseing concers/fears of an radical sindh. She represents those handful of members of the sindhis who continue to raise hopes despite denial of justice my Highest court of Pakistan.

Presented here is one such article in English for those who are unaware of Sindhi. This article was publidhed in Sindhi Daily Ibarat on 28 th. June 2012.


Why Sindhi Hindus are repeating their mistakes ??

After the verdict of 18th. April the impression is that we have lost all faith on the law of land. We understand it as an natural reaction when a court of the stature like Supreme Court itself proclaims such an verdict which for a moment at least makes us believe of hardly any difference between an dictatorial government and Supreme Court functioning under an democracy. This is what the general impression have been after Pakistan SC verdict from Rinkle Kumari to Asha Kumari cases.

Notwithstanding the fact that is the past too atrocities against the indigenous sons of the mother sindh who are being referred as Hindu Sindhis have been rampant ranging from Kidnapping to murders in open streets, who can forget the murder of young Hindu in open market at Jacacobad !!!

Shall we forget the killing of four hindu doctors at Chak ?

Who had till date delivered justice in all such cases ?? when there is nothing called justice in real terms for poor what the hell they should agitate for ? Everybody need to mark his own limits. The poor and unfortunate should take a note of their limits!!!!

Post 18 April have seen remarkable increase in Migration of Hindus from Sindh & Baluchistan primarily due to deteriorating security condition. There is little doubt in the fact that Hindu Sindhis are insecure but the point is are the Hindu only one insecure ?? I wish to put the question to all indigenous inhabitants of Sindh & Baluchistan are people of Sindh not being torched ? Are sindhi not being turned to minority ? If tomorrow Sindhis start dividing themselves into groups and began complaining that we are not being taken care off so shall we too migrate from Sindh ? Will our issues gets resolved with by giving up our own Dharti mata !!!! That is what the conspirator’s want that “Forced the indigenous people to migrate and make room for their own”!!!! That’s the very reason they are mischievously planning to attack us from behind. But instead of facing up to the issues all are busy packing up their bag & baggage f to say Goodbye !!! Look at the big cities of Sindh, so much so that even being a Sindhi is a sort of crime !!! Providing education to Sindhis is hardly permitted so shall we pull ourselves back from cities ???

Today I ask a simple straightforward question from Sindhis that tomorrow if our sindh is trouble and difficult times knock our door so shall, we dump our motherland ???

The mistakes committed in 1947 should not be repeated. If during that time we instead of giving up our land, had we preferred to fight with the intruders, Sindh would have been different world. If we vacate our homes that in a way implies that in addition to giving others room you are giving up your right to return as well and if repeated such will obviously hunt us. This is what intruders (of our Land) want and if after such a long time we are unable to comprehend it would be indeed unfortunate. The issues need to be addressed by standing firm and not by running away from our own Land. All what we need is introspect bring up the solution.

We should not expect the find solutions by emptying sindh nor expect any spectacular solution to our owes!!

We can only request them (Hindus ) that my giving up sindh they should not repeat the mistakes already committed once . If today the issue are hunting us tomorrow they might not be any issue in the first place but for GOD sake don’t deprive your future generation of their motherland simply because some issues had come up !!!

Comments 10

  • 1.Because their words are not heard upon by the higher authorities.
    2.The Muslim Sindhi also do not stand by them… and even if a few would want to do then they would not because they would know standing by a non muslim would result in criticism by the person who are professing Islam.
    3.The human rights org. are not given a due hear in matters pertaing to Non-Muslims.
    4. the international human rights organisations are not fully active… a condemnation is all they do.
    5 like wise the developed and nation also only criticise such acts. they are busy booming and prospering their own country.
    6 they fear for their lives and more than that the life of their family members by raising voice.
    7.their is no pressure group who would work for their upliftment…
    8. My observations may be wrong for more accuracy ask a Hindu Sindhi of Sindh Province (Pakistan) why they are doing so!!!


  • Pakistan has lost its battle as an Islamic Welfare State. It is either Militancy or Chaos that prevails all over the country. The sixty dependent years of post independence has put the country at a lost path, where a point of no return is obvious. The insecurity has left none to be secure, either it be Hindus in Sindh, it be Sindhis in Urban areas, it be Punjabis in Balochistan, it be Pathans anywhere in the borders, it be tenancy of Chaudhries, Jagirdars, Sardars, Nawabs, Khans, etc. etc. No corner of the land is lawful, all is shameful lawlessnes and that spares no one..We nee
    d to address it with its rootcauses.. and the answer is not a simple ‘Yes”….

  • Thank you Veegasji. Please continue to write such article to create awareness among the Sindhis.. Sindh must be protected and preserved at all cost. The Sindhis has been pushed to the corner so much so there is time for armed rebellion.

  • I am writing a final project on ”Reasons and Matters Behind Hindu migration of Sindh to India.
    I need of some articles related to my topic or books…
    please contact on umairmani70@gmail.com..

  • The problem started when we started dividing Sindhis, in “Sindhi Hindus and Sindhi Muslims” along with “Muslman Bhaur”.
    In above article there is question “Today I ask a simple straightforward question from Sindhis that tomorrow if our Sindh is trouble …. we dump our motherland ???. I’m asking “What is the current situation of Sindh? Why waiting for tomorrows? Isn’t Sindhi in trouble today?”
    In the end She is requesting them (Hindus), Sindhis are Only Sindhis and should be mentioned everywhere Sindhis. I feel humiliated when somebody calls me Sindhi Hindu.
    If somebody is leaving any motherland, only that generation suffers from that pain, not the generation that is born somewhere else. Sindhis who migrated they suffered the pain, not their future generation. It is national loss when we kick one generation, then next generation born in other country should be sincere with that motherland, not with their parents motherland.
    Let say I born in Sindh, how much I love Sindh that is only my story not of my children. If children of Sindh born Sindhis are born in United States. Then their parents should also all teach them to love their motherland, not parents motherland. Because they are son and daughters of that soil.
    Why do you except sons and daughters of Muhajirs as True Sindhis? Simply because they are born in Sindh and should be sincere with Sindh. Always the person wherever born and raised should be son of soil of that motherland.

    Until today we didn’t understand Shaikh Ayaz’s this poem:
    Aaoon A-Dharmi Ariya To Saan Changi Haan,
    Dhoor Dharm Puthiyan, Jey Wanjey Hote Hathaan

    Thank you dear, I hope I wrote bitter truth, sometimes it is very hard to digest.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *